Are You Clutch? ESPN's Keith Law Just Says No

Posted by Chip Stevenson

There's been a ton of debate in the last few years about whether a baseball player can be "clutch." The stats seem to go against the idea while people's selective memories and sense of nostalgia seem to support it. I'm not going to go there because I could probably write a million words on it, but I do think that people often wrongly define clutch.

In a chat on this week, Keith Law, an analyst who I would characterize as a stats guy and also an analyst who I enjoy reading, answered this question and, in the process, completely embarrassed himself by admitting to the world that he might not know what he is talking about.

ajd (chicago): Is that really the argument re: clutch? Or is it that the "clutch" player doesn't let the assorted jitters, nerves, etc. affect him when he's in a particularly pressure-laden situation? (I don't buy into "clutch" for what it's worth.) In any event, it's interesting that, in Manny's case (cf. Bill Simmons) when people say "clutch" they really mean "too stupid to know what's going on." Wonder if they'd say that about an articulate white guy!

SportsNation Keith Law: "Clutch" is supposed to be "better when the pressure's on." That means worse when the pressure's off, to me, at least. And that's a good point about Manny - I wonder if they'd say that if he was a non-Latino American who only spoke English. "Less comfortable in English" does not equal "stupid."

"Clutch" does NOT mean playing better when the pressure is on, as Keith Law puts it. Rather, clutch simply means playing well when the pressure is on. It's a small difference, but also a very important one.

If a player hits .330 during the season and goes on to hit .320 during the playoffs, games where the pressure is always on, I think that it would be perfectly acceptable to call him clutch if you believe in it. That player certainly didn't perform better like Keith Law thinks is required, and he even performed a little worse, but he would still be clutch in my book.

BallHype: hype it up!


Anonymous   says 2:36 PM

What is all this hype it up crap and stupid shit all over the place... this site used to be legit, too legit to quit! What's the deal?

MC Hammer is Bankrupt. We are trying to metaphorically steer clear of that path for this blog. We are trying to spread the name and fame of this blog. Like you said, it's too legit to quit.

Originally, we were getting about 5 readers a week. It wasn't economically efficient. There was no incentive to write for our 5 fans every day if they were just going to check once a week.

These links you see on the blog are sites that are helping get our name out there so we can get 100 avid readers a day, like we currently have had for 2 weeks running now. Once we become blog big time, like the blogs of ESPN, SI, and Deadspin we will then be legit enough to quit the silly links that take up space. Until then, we must reference the sites that are helping us out and attracting readers just like you.

PS- Leave your name next time so we can address you like a man...or woman or animal, whatever you are.

Thanks for the comment and keep on reading. The Reading Rainbow was my favorite show when I was younger. Now I hate rainbows, but I still love reading.

Post a Comment


In accordance with the Fair Use Copyright Law, Detroit4lyfe uses logos and registered trademarks to help inform the readers of D4L and to facilitate our hilarious banter.

Photos on Detroit4lyfe are, for the most part, used without permission but do not interfere with said owner's profit.

If you own a specific image on this site and want it removed, please e-mail us (Detroit4lyfe at gmail dot com) and we will be at first reluctant, yet ultimately happy to oblige.

Our Popularity

web stats

Link Referral

The topics tend to gravitate toward Detroit sports, but we also like outer space so sometimes there will be no gravity. Essentially, if you like sports with a humorous twang, this is the blog for you to bookmark4lyfe!


Blogs With Balls 1.0

Blogs With Balls 1.0
June 13, 2009 in NYC

Will the Wings Repeat as Stanley Cup Champions?

How Far Will the Pistons Go in the Playoffs?

Help Us Help You

Twitty Tweets

Oldies but Goodies

Topics We've Touched On

You Don't Know My Address...